The culprit, hidden in plain sight, was the form. They were trying to use Form 5305-B for a SIMPLE IRA. That form is not for SIMPLE IRAs at all, and it cost them a week of delays and a round of corrections.
If you have ever felt that same pit in your stomach, here is the straight answer you need: Form 5305-B is the IRS model agreement for a Health Savings Account trust, not a SIMPLE IRA. If you want a SIMPLE IRA, you need different documents. I will walk you through what 5305-B actually does, what it does not do, and which forms to use for SIMPLE and SEP plans, so you can set things up correctly the first time.
Key Takeaways
- Form 5305-B is the IRS model trust agreement for Health Savings Accounts, HSA trust version. It is not a SIMPLE IRA or SEP document. Keep it on file, you do not file it with the IRS.
- SIMPLE IRAs are adopted on Form 5304-SIMPLE or Form 5305-SIMPLE, depending on whether employees can choose the financial institution. Do not use 5305-B for SIMPLE.
- SIMPLE IRA employee deferrals are set by the IRS each year. For 2024 the limit is 16,000 with a 3,500 catch-up. For 2025 the limit increases to 16,500, with special “super” catch-up for ages 60–63 under SECURE 2.0. Verify limits annually.
- SIMPLE IRA distributions in the first two years can trigger a 25% early distribution tax, and rollovers are restricted during that window.
- HSAs have their own annual limits and HDHP rules. For 2025 the HSA limits are 4,300 self-only and 8,550 family, increasing to 4,400 and 8,750 in 2026.
Quick rule of thumb: if you are opening HSAs, Form 5305-B or 5305-C applies. If you are setting up SIMPLE IRAs, use 5304-SIMPLE or 5305-SIMPLE. If you are setting up SEPs, use 5305-SEP. Keep the lanes clean and you avoid most headaches.
What Form 5305-B Actually Is
Form 5305-B is the IRS’s model Health Savings Trust Account agreement. It is the boilerplate trust language that banks, trust companies, and approved trustees use when opening HSAs in trust form. You do not send it to the IRS. You adopt it with a qualified trustee, keep it with your records, and use it as the governing agreement for the HSA. There is also a custodial version, Form 5305-C, that serves the same purpose under a custodial arrangement.
A few practical notes:
- The form sets the legal framework for contributions, distributions, prohibited transactions, and trustee duties for HSAs.
- Your employees’ payroll HSA contributions can feed accounts opened under this agreement or the 5305-C custodial version.
- Employers making HSA contributions must follow comparability or cafeteria plan rules, explained in IRS Publication 969.
What Form 5305-B Is Not
Form 5305-B is not a retirement plan document. It is not used for:
- SIMPLE IRAs, which require Form 5304-SIMPLE or Form 5305-SIMPLE to adopt the plan.
- SEPs, which use Form 5305-SEP.
- Traditional or Roth IRAs, which use the 5305 and 5305-R series respectively.
Using 5305-B to stand up a SIMPLE IRA, a SEP, or any IRA will lead to rejected paperwork, corrected contributions, and wasted time. Keep these toolboxes separate.
Which Form Do I Use? A Fast Comparison
| Plan or Account | Purpose | IRS model form(s) | File with IRS? |
| HSA, trust version | Health Savings Account, trust | 5305-B | No |
| HSA, custodial version | Health Savings Account, custodial | 5305-C | No |
| SIMPLE IRA, participants choose institution | Adopt SIMPLE plan | 5304-SIMPLE | No |
| SIMPLE IRA, employer designates institution | Adopt SIMPLE plan | 5305-SIMPLE | No |
| SEP-IRA | Adopt SEP plan for employer contributions | 5305-SEP | No |
| Traditional IRA | IRA agreement | 5305 or 5305-A | No |
| Roth IRA | IRA agreement | 5305-R or 5305-RA | No |
Source references for the model forms listing are on the IRS retirement plan forms index.
Why the mix-ups happen
Many small employers and even seasoned admins assume anything with a “5305” label relates to IRAs. Some do. Form 5305-B does not. It lives in the HSA world. A quick double check against the IRS forms list before you order packets can save you a week of back-and-forth.
SIMPLE IRA Essentials, So You Do Not Use the Wrong Form
If your goal is a SIMPLE IRA for a small employer, here is the clean path.
- Use Form 5304-SIMPLE when participants can choose their own financial institution. Use Form 5305-SIMPLE when you require all contributions to go to one designated institution. Adopt the plan by completing and signing the correct model form, keep it on file, do not file it with the IRS, and provide the annual employee notice.
- Eligibility is generally 100 or fewer employees who earned 5,000 or more in the prior year, with employees eligible if they earned 5,000 in any two prior years and are expected to earn 5,000 this year.
- You must pick one employer funding method each year, either a match up to 3% of pay or a 2% nonelective to all eligible employees.
- Deposit timing matters. Employee salary reduction contributions must be deposited promptly, generally no later than 30 days after the end of the month withheld. Many SIMPLE plans qualify for a 7 business day safe harbor under DOL timing rules. Employer contributions are due by the tax return due date, including extensions.
SIMPLE IRA Limits for 2024 and 2025
- 2024 employee deferral limit is 16,000, with 3,500 catch-up at age 50 or older. The aggregate personal limit across multiple employer plans is 23,000 for 2024.
- 2025 employee deferral limit increases to 16,500. SECURE 2.0 also adds special catch-up rules for ages 60–63 that can increase the catch-up for certain plans, often discussed as a “super” catch-up for SIMPLEs. Confirm your plan’s features before you communicate numbers.
Pro tip for controllers and payroll teams, codify the annual update process each fall. Document where you pull the numbers, who approves the update, and when you refresh payroll election forms and employee notices.
The SIMPLE IRA Two-Year Rule and 25% Early Distribution Tax
SIMPLE IRAs carry a special two-year clock. Withdrawals in the first two years are subject to an additional 25% early distribution tax if the normal IRA exceptions do not apply. During that same two-year period, rollovers are restricted. You can move money only to another SIMPLE IRA. After the two-year period, standard IRA rollover options open up. Make sure your 1099-R coding and any trustee-to-trustee transfers respect this rule.
If you are ever unsure, check the first date your employer deposited to that participant’s SIMPLE IRA. That is day one for the two-year window.
HSAs at a Glance, Because Form 5305-B Lives Here
If you are setting up HSAs, 5305-B is right in your lane.
- Purpose. HSAs are tax-favored accounts for people covered by an HSA-eligible high deductible health plan. Contributions can be made by employees or employers, and qualified medical withdrawals are tax free. Publication 969 is your operating manual.
- Limits. For 2025, the HSA contribution limits are 4,300 self-only and 8,550 family. For 2026, the limits rise to 4,400 and 8,750. The 55+ catch-up stays at 1,000.
- HDHP thresholds. The IRS also updates minimum deductibles and maximum out-of-pocket limits each year for HSA-qualifying HDHPs. Always confirm the current thresholds before you communicate eligibility.
5305-B vs 5305-C, Which One Should You Use?
- 5305-B, the trust version, is common when a bank or trust company serves as trustee under a trust agreement.
- 5305-C, the custodial version, is used when an HSA is set up as a custodial account. Many retail HSA providers use the custodial format. Both are IRS model documents. Your provider will tell you which vehicle they support.
How to Complete and Adopt Form 5305-B Correctly
Here is a straightforward, repeatable way to keep 5305-B clean and compliant.
- Confirm you are using the current IRS model form and that your trustee supports the trust version. Many providers offer the custodial version, 5305-C, instead. Check before payroll begins.
- Open and complete the PDF with a current PDF reader so all fields render properly. Save a signed copy to your plan files and, if applicable, provide employees with the account agreement from your bank or HSA provider.
- Align your payroll setup with Publication 969 rules. If you contribute as an employer outside a cafeteria plan, apply the comparability rules or route contributions through the Section 125 plan to use the separate cafeteria plan rules. Communicate clearly which approach you use.
- Calendar annual updates. Each fall, confirm next year’s HSA limits and HDHP thresholds before open enrollment. Update your employee communications and payroll caps accordingly.
HSAs are not filed with the IRS when opened. You keep the executed agreement with the trustee’s file set, the same way you retain SIMPLE or SEP plan documents.
Common Mistakes We See, And Quick Fixes
- Using 5305-B to set up a SIMPLE IRA. Fix by adopting the correct SIMPLE form, notifying employees, and reclassifying any contributions that were misrouted.
- Mixing up rollover rules for SIMPLE IRAs in the first two years. Fix by confirming first deposit date and, if needed, correcting any nonpermitted transfer with proper 1099-R reporting.
- Announcing the wrong limits. Fix by pulling limits directly from IRS releases and trusted summaries, then documenting the approval trail for your payroll changes.
Where To Find Official Guidance Fast
- Model forms and retirement plan form index for IRAs, SIMPLE, and SEPs.
- SIMPLE plan setup and annual notice requirements, plus timing rules.
- SIMPLE two-year rule and 25% early distribution tax details.
- Publication 969 for HSA rules, employer contributions, and cafeteria plan interactions.
- Annual HSA and HDHP limits for 2025 and 2026.
FAQs
Is Form 5305-B filed with the IRS?
No. Like other IRS model account agreements, 5305-B is adopted with a qualified trustee and kept on file. You do not submit it to the IRS when you open the HSA.
Can I use 5305-B to set up a SIMPLE IRA or a SEP?
No. Use 5304-SIMPLE or 5305-SIMPLE for SIMPLE plans, and 5305-SEP for SEPs. 5305-B is specifically for HSAs.
What are the SIMPLE IRA employee deferral limits now?
For 2024, the deferral limit is 16,000 with a 3,500 catch-up. For 2025, it rises to 16,500, and certain plans for ages 60–63 allow a larger catch-up under SECURE 2.0. Always verify the latest figures before open enrollment.
What happens if an employee takes a SIMPLE IRA distribution in the first two years?
If no exception applies, the additional early distribution tax jumps to 25%, and rollovers are restricted to another SIMPLE IRA during that period. After two years, standard IRA rollover options apply.
What are the current HSA limits?
For 2025, HSAs allow 4,300 self-only and 8,550 family. For 2026, limits increase to 4,400 and 8,750. Catch-up at 55+ remains 1,000.
A short note for busy firm owners
If your internal team is already stretched by peak season, year-end, or payroll cycles, these document choices and annual thresholds can slip through the cracks. At Accountably, we build SOPs and review steps that keep plan documents, notices, and payroll caps aligned, then we monitor the dates so updates do not get missed. It is not about more people, it is about clean, repeatable delivery. We only mention this because getting the right form in the right process is exactly the kind of guardrail that protects deadlines and trust.